Despite years of intense academic and public debate, there is little clarity as to the philosophical foundations for many of the emerging policy choices. Human cloning requires us to think about the nature of a human embryo, the moral status of the human embryo, what is required by respect for human embryos, and whether the distinction between spare embryos that is, those left over from in vitro. England has allowed cloning human embryos for therapeutic use only. Appeals to human dignity, and to the moral obligation to protect it, have been a feature of responses to the cloning of dolly the sheep nature 385, 8108. Ever since the advent of cloning, there have been arguments for and against this process. No two countries have adopted identical regulatory measures on cloning. Supreme court rules that live, humanmade organisms are patentable material. Dec 16, 2019 opponents of human cloning feel that is a mute debate, since the technology is primarily unsuccessful. Noting the general consensus reached at the national and international levels since the fiftieth world health. The regulation of human cloning continues to be a significant national and international policy issue. Reproductive cloning is moral 14 panayiotis zavos 3. The legal and ethical issues of cloning that make it.
The advantages and disadvantages of human cloning raise moral, ethical, scientific and safety questions. Since the artificial cloning of dolly the sheep, scientists have launched the question whether in a not so distant future a human being will also be created artificially. Judging from the official documents dealing with the moral and legal aspects of human reproductive cloning there seems to be a nearly worldwide consensus that reproductive cloning is incompatible with human dignity. This book is one of many published since the successful cloning of dolly reported in nature in february 1997, and gives a specific american view of ethical and legal aspects of the issues raised concerning applications to the human. The ethical implications of human clones have been much alluded to, but have seldom been examined with any rigour. Secondly, human cloning may violate two fundamental principles which human rights are based on. The process of being natural is all that matters, so that no body will be blamed of the outcome. The ethics of human cloning has become a great issue over the past few years. Dec, 2004 those who hold that cloning violates human dignity will no doubt point to article 1, which requires parties to the convention to protect the dignity and identity of all human beings. A recent poll has shown the differences in opinions with half as many women as men approving of the process. Primer on ethics and human cloning kyrene school district. Scientists have changed human blood cells into immature egg cells. Cloning fact sheet nhgri national human genome research.
The advocates for both sides of the issue have many reasons to clone or not to clone. The french parliament on july 9, 2004 adopted a new bioethics law that allows embryonic stem cell research but considers human cloning a crime against the human species. The cloning of a man, sparks a worldwide debate on cloning ethics. It requires over 100 embryos to create one viable animal clone in many circumstances. Many countries or jurisdictions have legally banned human cloning or are in the process of doing so. Supreme court rules that live, human made organisms are patentable material. Ethical, scientific and social implications of cloning in. Jul 29, 2003 the regulation of human cloning continues to be a significant national and international policy issue. Human cloning more typically refers to reproductive cloning, the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer scnt to obtain eggs that could develop. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research. Mass human cloning may soon be upon us evolution news.
The ethics of reproductive cloning i turn first to the ethics of reproductive cloning,and then to cloning for biomedical research. Because of this stalemate,no federal ban on cloning has been enacted. Human cloning is a different means of reproduction than sexual reproduction, but it is a means that can serve individuals interest in reproducing. Cloning would irrevocably confuse the essential concepts of being a mother, a father, a child, an aunt, an uncle, and so on, and humanity as we know it would come to its end. The ethical implications of human cloning harvard university. Ethical, scientific and social implications of cloning in human health the fiftyfirst world health assembly, recalling resolution wha50. Therapeutic cloning, while offering the potential for treating humans suffering from disease or injury, would require the destruction of human embryos in the test tube. The case for banning human reproductive cloning is not difficult to. I turn first to the ethics of reproductive cloning, and then to cloning for biomed ical research. However, significantly more nuclear transfer generated embryos fail during pregnancy than would fail in sexual reproduction, and a substantial. Even before wilmuts announcement, human cloning had been made illegal in nearly all countries in europe and had been condemned by the council of europe council of europe 1986. The possibility that human beings will be cloned elicits widespread opprobrium from a wide spectrum of the population, christians included, so much so that calls for its banning are frequently heard. The paper examines some of the major public and official responses to cloning by authorities such as president clinton, the. Biological, ethical, and social considerations ncbi.
No other science has advanced more dramatically during the past several decades or yielded so many palpable improvements in human welfare. Unavoidably, the chapters are of different quality, and it sometimes takes a while to fathom the angle from which the problem is seen. Recent events in britain and the united states have shown that human cloning, as well as cloning animals, raises important ethical questions. Jun 06, 2012 the ethics of human cloning today biological science is rising on a wall of worry. Here is a discussion about the ethical issues that have arisen concerned with cloning humans. The threat of human cloning ethics, recent developments, and the case for action summer 2015, pp. Ethical aspects within human cloning sciencedirect. Japans cabinet council for science and technology policy voted on july 23, 2004 to adopt. Yes, human cloning should be permitted chris macdonald phd patricia bairds discussion of human cloning annals rcpsc, june 2000 challenges the prospect of nucleartransfer cloning for the purposes of human reproduction. A human embryothe being created by human cloningis nothing less than a human being in the earliest stages of natural development.
In 2005, the united nations adopted a declaration on human cloning, which calls for a universal ban on human cloning. Artificial cloning processes have yet to be developed, and they may never be brought to light because of the numerous ethical and moral concerns involved with the technology that would allow a genetically identical copy of an existing or previously existing individual. The proposal to enhance the human genetic endowment by genetic cloning of eminent individuals is not warranted. In fact, over 90% of human cloning attempts have been labeled as failure, which means that the human dna is only put at risk during the process. The paper examines some of the major public and official responses to cloning by authorities such as president. Though genetically identical, cloned humans are technically due the same rights of any human. Dr birnbachers main fields of interest are ethics, applied ethics and. Ethics and cloning british medical bulletin oxford academic. Many countries disallow reproductive cloning because of these questions, but some do allow research. It highlights the challenges associated with the regulation of a controversial and rapidly evolving area of science and sheds light on a regulatory framework that can accommodate this reality. Pdf on sep 22, 2015, marin gillis and others published the ethics of human cloning find, read and cite all the research you need on. She distinguished three different forms of this argument and showed that for each, pursuing stem cell research will not inevitably lead to human.
In japan, human cloning is a crime punishable by up to 10 years in prison. Ethics and cloning british medical bulletin oxford. Protestantorganized bodies, such as the world council of churches 1975, 1982, 1989 and the national council of churches of christ 1980, 1983, 1986, as well as some individual. The notion of human dignity is commonly used to justify cloning laws.
Philosophy professor barbara mackinnon university of san francisco, editor of human cloning. The foucaultian standard of ethics dictates the integration of individual codes and standards of morality and behavior into the collective morality but not the elimination of individualityshogun 1999 which would be the effect of replication through cloning. Therapeutic cloning can save lives 30 raymond barglow 5. These ethical concerns have prompted several nations to pass. In 2005, the united nations adopted a declaration on human cloning, which calls for. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research markkula. There is, however, an additional protocol on the prohibition of cloning human beings. Science, ethics, and public policy, began by discussing the distinction between reproductive and therapeutic cloning and the slippery slope argument. Embryo cloning still depends on a human egg from a woman and sperm from a man.
As you can see, human dna can be contaminated, and the chances of success are very rare. Although scientists have successfully brought back an extinct species through the technologies and understanding of the research in this field, the results were less than spectacular. Mammalian cloning, through this nuclear transfer process, has resulted in the birth of hundreds of organisms to date. Reproductive cloning experiments would be punishable by up to 20 y in prison. Human cloning is the creation of a genetically identical copy or clone of a human. Its purpose was to bring together experts from the fields of science, religion, ethics, and law to discuss how the state of california should proceed in regulating human cloning and stem cell. Understanding the complexity of these regulatory variations is essential. I was astonished at kasss mastery of both the issue and the writing as opposed to wilson. The technology for successful human cloning is within our reach. A fundamental argument is that cloning is ethically wrong and various religious groups have rejected it saying that cloning is equivalent to playing god. Others see human cloning as a way to avoid passing on a deleterious gene that runs in the family without having to undergo embryo screening or embryo selection. Certain countries abroad have stricter standards, and more than 50 have legally banned research efforts on reproductive human cloning source.
The possibility of person cloning has raised controversies. The case for banning human reproductive cloning is. Therapeutic cloning is immoral 37 william saunders 6. A few more cautious voices were heard, both suggesting some possible benefits from the. Wilsons essays simply dont compare in quality to the time and thought that obviously went into kasss. Human cloning in the form of identical twins is the closest comparison that we have to this scientific concept at this time. Human embryo cloning just tweaks apart a zygote at the two cell stage, changing a single twocell form of life into two onecell forms of life. The announcement of her birth in 1997 sparked a heated debate about the ethics of human reproductive cloning, resulting in most countries. But the legal, ethical, and social implications keep us from using it. Human cloning the science and ethics of nuclear transplantation. Jul 21, 2015 human cloning may refer to therapeutic cloning, particularly the cloning of embryonic cells to obtain organs for transplantation or for treating injured nerve cells and other health purposes.
The ethics of human cloning the successful cloning of an adult sheep, announced in scotland this past february, is one of the most dramatic recent examples of a scientific discovery becoming a public issue. But the dangers for the first clone pale in comparison to the ethical issues that will arise should cloning succeed in produc ing a healthy child, and become part of. This paper examines the possible uses and abuses of human cloning and draws out the principal ethical dimensions, both of what might be. Mar 12, 2019 human cloning would face the same dangers as animal cloning. Sep 22, 2015 pdf on sep 22, 2015, marin gillis and others published the ethics of human cloning find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. However, significantly more nuclear transfer generated embryos fail during pregnancy than. A dialogue on state regulation was convened october 12, 2001, by the markkula center for applied ethics at santa clara university. Today biological science is rising on a wall of worry. In some countries, including france and singapore, reproductive cloning of humans is a criminal offence.
Pdf on sep 22, 2015, marin gillis and others published the ethics of human cloning find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. It does not refer to the natural conception and delivery of identical twins. Human cloning as an asexual method of creating progeny would distort the sense of family and natural relationships within it. The basis for this justification is that reproductive human. Pdf human cloning the science and ethics of nuclear. The reasons for the strength of this opposition are profound and serious. The ethics of human cloning today biological science is rising on a wall of worry.
The term is generally used to refer to artificial human cloning, which is the reproduction of human cells and tissue. This paper examines the possible uses and abuses of human cloning and draws out the principal ethical dimensions, both of what might be done and its meaning. The basis for this justification is that reproductive human cloning. The ethics of reproductive cloning i turn first to the ethics of reproductive cloning,and then to cloning for biomed. Human cloning has been accomplished, but the field remains generally stalled because of a shortage of human eggs one needed per cloning attempt and eggs for use in research are hard to come by. Using the most reliable information available, we have. You and we and everybody else on the planet were at an earlier stage of our lives human embryos, just as every reader of these words was once a toddler, and before that an infant, and before that a fetus. Lastly, having certain expectations for cloned children may exert significant amounts of psychological pressure upon them. The threat of human cloning ethics, recent developments, and the case for action, the new atlantis, no. People have very different views of what is natural. Cloning would irrevocably confuse the essential concepts of being a mother, a father, a child, an aunt, an uncle, and so. Full text get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 206k, or click on a page image below to browse page by page. During the last few months, various commentators scientists and theologians.
65 542 249 1279 1609 802 1276 869 1419 265 56 990 937 71 243 911 587 468 683 985 1126 848 699 844 94 438 75 489 594 793 472 369 1465 722 454 746